UK · Tax year 2026/27
Umbrella vs Limited Calculator
The two main UK contractor routes, side by side at the same headline rate. Models the full chain: corporation tax, dividend tax, employer NI, apprenticeship levy, umbrella margin, and pension on each side.
Last reviewed 2026-11-17 · 2026/27 HMRC rates · Author: Salarybueno
Assignment rate
£110,000
Day rate × billable days. The same rate is fed to both routes for an apples-to-apples comparison.
Limited wins by
£3,514
Per year — assumes outside-IR35 status for the limited route.
How the comparison works
Both sides start from the same client-paid assignment rate. That keeps the comparison honest — agencies routinely quote a higher headline rate for limited routes (because they don't have to fund employer NI inside the rate), so comparing two different quoted rates is misleading.
On the umbrella side, the assignment rate is reduced first by the umbrella margin, then employer NI and the apprenticeship levy are deducted before computing the gross salary that goes through PAYE. On the limited side, the assignment rate arrives in the company bank account, the director takes a £12,570 salary (with employer NI on the slice above £5,000), the rest is taxed at corporation tax (19% / 25% with marginal relief), then dividends are personally taxed.
Pension contributions are modelled in both routes: as salary sacrifice on the umbrella side (reducing the gross salary before tax/NI) and as employer contributions on the limited side (reducing company profit before corp tax). Both are tax-efficient; the limited side is slightly more flexible because there is no annual allowance interaction with employee NI.
When each route wins
- Umbrella wins when the contract is inside IR35, the rate is below ~£40,000 of contract income, the contract is short-term (under 6 months), or you value zero admin overhead.
- Limited wins when the contract is genuinely outside IR35, the rate is above ~£60,000, you intend to contract for multiple years, and you have an accountant.
- Mixed situations (some clients inside IR35, some outside) usually default to limited with the inside-IR35 work routed through the company as deemed payments.
- Mortgage, pension, and dividend timing can change the calculus — some lenders prefer umbrella PAYE history; some prefer two years of company accounts.
Frequently asked
Which is better — umbrella or limited?
It depends on three things: (1) IR35 status — limited only beats umbrella when the contract is genuinely outside IR35; (2) headline rate — the limited advantage grows with income, especially above £60,000; (3) ongoing admin tolerance — limited needs an accountant and yearly filings, umbrella is hands-off. For inside-IR35 work, umbrella usually wins because there's no dividend route to take advantage of.
Does the limited route assume outside IR35?
Yes. The calculator runs the limited side using corporation tax, salary, and dividends — which is only legal extraction if the contract is genuinely outside IR35. If the contract is inside IR35, the limited company has to pay you the deemed payment via PAYE and the result collapses back to roughly the umbrella outcome (minus the umbrella margin). For inside-IR35 work, use the inside-IR35 calculator instead.
How much should an umbrella cost?
Compliant umbrellas charge a flat margin, typically £15–£30 per week or £65–£130 per month. Beware umbrellas that quote a percentage of your assignment rate — that often signals a tax-avoidance scheme, which HMRC will pursue you for years later. The Freelancer & Contractor Services Association (FCSA) accreditation is the most common quality signal.
What break-even rate makes the limited route worthwhile?
Roughly £40,000–£50,000 of annual contract income, depending on expenses. Below that, the savings vs umbrella are eaten up by accountant fees (£900–£1,500/year), Companies House filings, and the time cost of running a company. Above £80,000, the limited route is usually clearly ahead — typically £3,000–£8,000 per year more in your pocket on the same contract.
Can I switch routes mid-contract?
Yes — many contractors take an umbrella for the first contract while they incorporate a limited company, then switch once they have the company set up. Each route has separate tax records, so HMRC handles them as distinct streams. Note that opening and closing limited companies frequently can attract HMRC attention; treat the company as a multi-year vehicle.
Drill in
Outside IR35 calculator
Full limited company breakdown.
Drill in
Inside IR35 calculator
Deemed-payment net for inside-IR35 work.
Convert
Day rate ↔ salary
Permanent role equivalent.
Methodology & assumptions
Both routes use HMRC 2026/27 rates. Limited route assumes a single sole director taking £12,570 salary plus dividends (no other shareholders). Employer NI applies above the £5,000 secondary threshold at 15%. Corporation tax: 19% small profits / 25% main / marginal relief 50–250k. Dividend allowance £500; rates 10.75% / 35.75% / 39.35%. Umbrella uses a 46-week year for margin calculation. England/Wales bands are used here; Scottish-aware variants are available on the inside-IR35 and day-rate calculators.
This calculator gives an estimate, not advice. Always confirm specifics with a qualified UK accountant. We may earn a referral fee on partner links.